IB Middle Years Programme · Chemistry MYP Year 4

Pure Substances, Mixtures and Separation

Cover illustration for Pure Substances, Mixtures and Separation (Chemistry MYP Year 4).
MYP · Chemistry MYP Year 4

Pure Substances, Mixtures and Separation

MYP Year 4 Chemistry — Pure Substances, Mixtures and Separation

16 min readStandardCore data-response topic — expect melting-point classification tables, solubility-curve reading, and separation-method justification questions across Criterion A (knowledge) and Criterion B (inquiry/data) tasks.

This topic is really one question asked six different ways: how do you know what you're looking at, and how do you pull it apart? Examiners test it almost entirely through data — a melting point range, a solubility curve, a chromatogram — so the skill isn't memorising definitions, it's reading evidence and matching it to the right classification or technique. Get the sharp-vs-range criterion for purity solid first; everything else in this chapter builds on it.

Overview: Purity, Mixtures and Separation

Chemistry starts by sorting matter into two boxes: pure substances (elements and compounds — one type of particle, fixed composition, constant physical properties) and mixtures (two or more substances physically combined in a variable ratio, each keeping its own properties). Everything else in this chapter — solubility, filtration, distillation, chromatography — is really just a toolkit for telling the two apart and for un-mixing mixtures back into their pure components.

  • The single most-tested skill: use melting/boiling point behaviour (sharp value vs range) as evidence of purity, not appearance.
  • Separation technique choice always comes back to one question: what physical property differs between the components? (particle size, magnetism, boiling point, solubility, colour/adsorption).
  • MYP loves ‘classify and justify’ questions — a bare label (‘mixture’) with no reasoning tied to data scores zero for the justification mark.

The shape of the chapter

Command terms that drive the marks in this topic

Command termWhat it demandsAOMark-earning move
DefineGive the precise scientific meaning, not an example.Criterion AMust include ‘fixed composition’ and ‘one type of particle/element or compound’ — an example alone (e.g. ‘like water’) earns 0.
ClassifyAssign to a category (element / compound / mixture) using a stated criterion.Criterion ACategory alone is often only half the mark — the criterion used (mp range, composition) must be named.
Justify / ExplainGive reasoning that links evidence to a conclusion.Criterion A/D‘Because it's pure’ restates the conclusion — must cite the actual evidence (e.g. ‘the 0.5°C range matches a single substance’).
DeduceReach a conclusion using ONLY the data given in the question.Criterion BBringing in outside numbers instead of the table provided loses the mark even if the final answer is numerically right.
DistinguishState the point(s) of difference between two named things.Criterion ADescribing each thing separately without a direct contrast scores lower than a stated discriminator.
DescribeGive a detailed, accurate account without justifying why.Criterion AAdding unrequested explanation doesn't gain extra credit but also isn't penalised — however skipping detail (units, conditions) loses marks.

Key point

Purity is a property of the SUBSTANCE'S BEHAVIOUR (sharp mp/bp, fixed composition), not of how many elements it contains. NaCl is one pure compound made of two elements — it is not ‘impure’ or ‘a mixture’ just because sodium and chlorine are both present.

Pure and Impure Substances

A pure substance contains only one type of particle — either a single element (only one kind of atom, e.g. ) or a single compound (atoms of two or more elements joined in one fixed ratio, e.g. ). Because every particle is identical, a pure substance has constant, reproducible physical properties: a sharp, fixed melting point and boiling point. A mixture contains two (or more) substances physically combined in a ratio that can vary — its melting point smears out into a range, and is usually depressed below the purest component's true value, because foreign particles disrupt the regular packing of the lattice.

  • Sharp mp/bp (narrow range, often quoted to ±0.5 °C) → pure. A wide range (several °C or more) → mixture/impure sample.
  • A sharp range on its own only proves purity — to prove identity you must compare the value to a known literature melting point for that specific substance.
  • Elements and compounds are both pure; only combinations of different pure substances in variable proportion count as mixtures.
  • The law of definite/multiple proportions is the compositional signature of a compound: the masses of one element combining with a fixed mass of another element are always in small whole-number ratios — mixtures show no such constraint.
Pure substance
Matter made of only one type of particle (a single element or a single compound) with a fixed chemical composition and constant physical properties.Includes compounds — 'one type of particle' means one type of formula unit/molecule, not one type of atom.
Element
A pure substance made of only one type of atom; cannot be broken into simpler substances by chemical means.
Compound
A pure substance formed when atoms of two or more elements bond chemically in a fixed whole-number ratio; can only be split back into elements by a chemical reaction.
Mixture
Two or more pure substances physically combined (not chemically bonded) in a ratio that can vary; each component keeps its own chemical identity and properties.

Heating curve: pure substance vs mixture

The flat plateau is the tell: temperature stalls at one exact value only while a pure solid melts.

Pure substance, e.g. sulfurImpure/mixture sampleSharp melting point (80°C)Melting range (60–70°C)

Worked example

Classifying samples from melting-point data

[3]
Sample A (elemental sulfur, ) melts at 80.0–80.5 °C. Sample B (sodium chloride, NaCl) melts at 100.0–100.5 °C. Sample C (a sulfur–sodium chloride mixture) melts at 60.0–70.0 °C. Evaluate the claim: 'All solids containing only one type of particle and having a fixed composition are pure substances', using this data.

Worked example

Using literature values to test identity, not just purity

[2]
Substance X melts at 118–121 °C. Reference data: benzoic acid () melts at 122 °C; naphthalene () melts at 80 °C. What does X's melting behaviour suggest about its purity and probable identity?

Worked example

Fixed composition and the law of multiple proportions

[3]
The mass of oxygen combining with 1.00 g of nitrogen is 0.571 g in , 1.14 g in , and 2.28 g in . (a) Deduce the pattern in these masses. (b) Calculate the mass of oxygen that would combine with 1.00 g of nitrogen in , and check it fits the pattern.

Sharp mp proves purity, not identity

Assuming a sharp, narrow melting range by itself proves what a substance IS.

Consequence: Loses the mark when no literature value is given to compare against (as with Sample Z, whose literature value is unknown) — you can only conclude 'this is pure', not 'this is X'.

Fix: State explicitly: sharp range = pure substance (purity claim); matching a specific literature value = identity claim. Never claim identity without a reference value to compare to.

Commercial 'purity' vs chemical purity

Treating 99.9% pure copper as chemically 100% pure because it's labelled 'pure' industrially.

Consequence: Marks lost for failing to distinguish the strict chemical definition (100% one substance, one type of particle) from an industrial purity grade.

Fix: Answer with both: chemically, true purity means zero foreign particles; 99.9% copper is described as 'pure' commercially but the remaining 0.1% impurity still measurably affects properties like electrical conductivity and corrosion resistance.

Extracting pure copper — at an environmental cost

Copper ore is mostly rock mixed with copper sulfide (). Smelting heats the ore to release pure copper metal, but oxidises the sulfide and releases gas as a by-product. In the atmosphere, reacts with water vapour to form sulfurous/sulfuric acid, contributing to acid rain — this acidifies lakes and soil (killing fish and damaging plant roots), corrodes limestone buildings and metal structures, and irritates the human respiratory tract in surrounding communities. Separating a pure substance from an ore is never chemically 'free' — the by-products matter too.

Key takeaways

  • Purity = fixed composition + one type of particle (element OR compound) + constant physical properties.
  • Sharp/narrow melting range (≈≤1 °C) → pure; wide range and depression below the true value → mixture.
  • A sharp range proves purity only — match to a literature value to claim identity.
  • Compounds obey the law of (multiple) definite proportions — combining masses land on simple whole-number ratios; mixtures do not.

Solutions, Colloids and Suspensions

Mixtures aren't all the same kind of mixture — how thoroughly one substance disperses through another depends on particle size. A solution disperses down to individual ions/molecules (sub-nanometre), giving a mixture so uniform it looks like a single substance. A suspension contains particles large enough to be seen and to settle under gravity. A colloid sits in between: particles too small to settle out on their own, but large enough to scatter light.

  • Solutions: homogeneous throughout, never settle, pass through any filter, don't scatter a light beam.
  • Colloids: look uniform to the naked eye but scatter light visibly (Tyndall effect) because particles are big enough to reflect photons but small enough to stay dispersed via constant collision with solvent molecules (Brownian motion).
  • Suspensions: visibly cloudy/heterogeneous, particles settle on standing, and are removed by ordinary filter paper.
Solution
A homogeneous mixture where solute particles are dispersed at the molecular/ionic level in a solvent; does not scatter light and cannot be separated by filtration.
Colloid
A mixture where particles (roughly 1–1000 nm) are dispersed throughout a medium finely enough to stay suspended indefinitely, but coarsely enough to scatter light (Tyndall effect).
Suspension
A heterogeneous mixture containing visible, relatively large particles that settle out over time and can be removed by filtration.
Tyndall effect
The scattering of a light beam by dispersed particles in a colloid, making the beam's path visible; true solutions do not show this effect.

Solution vs colloid vs suspension

PropertySolutionColloidSuspension
Particle size< 1 nm (ions/molecules)~1–1000 nm
1000 nm (visible)
AppearanceClear, uniformOften cloudy but uniformVisibly cloudy/heterogeneous
Settles on standing?NeverNo (stays dispersed)Yes, over time
Filterable with paper?NoNo (needs ultrafiltration/membrane)Yes
Tyndall effect?No (beam invisible)Yes (beam visibly scattered)Yes but usually just looks opaque
ExampleSalt water, sugar syrupMilk, fog, gelatineMuddy river water, sand in water

Tyndall effect: solution vs colloid

Same torch, same angle — the only difference is particle size big enough to scatter light.

True solution (e.g. salt water)Colloid (e.g. milk)no scattering – beam invisibleTyndall effect – visible beam

Worked example

Classifying an unknown cloudy liquid

[2]
A cloudy liquid scatters a laser beam clearly (Tyndall effect) but does not settle after standing for 24 hours, and passes straight through ordinary filter paper. Classify the sample.

Mnemonic

Solutions Simply dissolve, Colloids Scatter light, Suspensions Settle

Three S-words track the size ladder in order: Simply dissolved (smallest, solution) → Scatters light without settling (colloid) → Settles out completely (suspension, largest particles).

Purity and mixture mix-ups

Concept AConcept BThe distinction that matters
ColloidSuspensionBoth look cloudy, but a colloid never settles and passes through filter paper (particles stay suspended via Brownian motion); a suspension settles out and is removed by filtration.
Pure compoundMixtureA compound (e.g. NaCl) has ONE fixed melting point because it is one type of particle; a mixture melts over a RANGE because it contains two or more different substances at a variable ratio.
MixtureImpure sample of a compoundA mixture usually shows a wide, strongly depressed melting range (large amounts of a second substance); an impure compound shows only a small deviation close to the pure literature value (trace contamination), e.g. 801–810 °C against a literature value of 801 °C.

Real-world application

Milk, fog and whipped cream are colloids (fat/water droplets or air bubbles dispersed but too small to settle); muddy river water and paint pigment settling in a tin are suspensions; sugar or salt dissolved in water are solutions. This is why milk needs shaking, not settling, to redistribute cream — it's not going to separate on its own like a suspension would.

Key takeaways

  • Particle size decides the category: solution < colloid < suspension.
  • Diagnostic tests, in order of usefulness: does it settle? Is it filterable? Does it scatter light (Tyndall)?
  • Never classify by appearance alone — cloudiness alone doesn't distinguish colloid from suspension.

Solubility and Factors Affecting It

Solubility is the maximum mass of a solute that will dissolve in a fixed mass of solvent (usually 100 g water) at a stated temperature, forming a saturated solution — one that cannot dissolve any more solute at that temperature (extra solute simply sits undissolved). A solution that has less than the maximum dissolved is unsaturated; one forced to hold more than the equilibrium amount (by careful cooling of a hot saturated solution) is supersaturated and unstable.

  • For most solids, solubility rises with temperature — more thermal energy helps break the solid lattice apart and disperse ions/molecules into solution.
  • For gases, solubility FALLS with rising temperature (and rises with pressure) — heating gives dissolved gas molecules enough energy to escape the liquid, which is why warm fizzy drinks go flat faster.
  • 'Like dissolves like': polar solvents (water) dissolve polar/ionic solutes well; non-polar solvents dissolve non-polar solutes well.
  • Stirring, crushing the solid, and heating all change the RATE at which the maximum amount dissolves — none of them change the actual solubility value itself.

Solubility

Solubility is the mass of solute (g) that saturates 100 g of solvent at a given, stated temperature.

— solubility (g per 100 g solvent)
— mass of solute dissolved at saturation (g)
Memorise

Always quote a temperature alongside a solubility value — the number is meaningless without it.

Solubility curves for KNO3 and NaCl

Steep curve = strongly temperature-dependent solubility; flat line = barely affected by temperature.

Potassium nitrate (KNO3)Sodium chloride (NaCl)60°C, 110 g/100g20°C, 32 g/100g

Worked example

Reading a solubility curve to find crystallised mass

[3]
50 g of water is saturated with potassium nitrate at 60 °C, where the solubility curve gives 110 g KNO3 per 100 g water. The solution is then cooled to 20 °C, where solubility is 32 g per 100 g water. Calculate the mass of KNO3 that crystallises out on cooling.

Rate of dissolving vs solubility

Saying stirring, crushing, or warming 'increases the solubility' of a solid.

Consequence: Conflates rate and equilibrium amount — loses the mark on 'state which factors affect solubility' style questions.

Fix: Only temperature (and pressure, for gases) change the actual solubility value (maximum mass dissolvable). Stirring, particle size and temperature (as a rate factor) only change how FAST that maximum is reached — the ceiling itself doesn't move due to stirring or crushing.

Examiner tip

When 'reading the solubility curve' is asked, always state the unit (g per 100 g water) and the temperature it applies to in your answer — a bare number with no units or temperature loses the accuracy mark even if the value read off the graph is correct.

Key takeaways

  • Solubility = max mass of solute per 100 g solvent at a stated temperature (saturated solution).
  • Solid solubility usually rises with temperature; gas solubility falls with temperature and rises with pressure.
  • Always rescale 'per 100 g' solubility data to the actual solvent mass given in the question before subtracting.
  • Stirring/crushing/heating change rate of dissolving, NOT the solubility ceiling itself.

Filtration, Evaporation and Crystallization

These three techniques all separate a solid from a liquid, but they answer different questions. Filtration separates an insoluble solid from a liquid using a barrier (filter paper) that lets liquid through but traps particles too big to pass. Evaporation removes the solvent entirely (boiling it off) to leave the dissolved solute behind as solid residue — fast, but destroys heat-sensitive solutes and gives small, impure crystals. Crystallisation grows large, pure crystals by evaporating a solution only until it becomes saturated, then cooling it slowly so the solute comes out of solution gradually as an ordered solid, leaving impurities behind in the remaining liquid (mother liquor).

  • Choose filtration when the mixture is a solid + liquid where the solid does NOT dissolve.
  • Choose evaporation-to-dryness only when the solute is stable at high heat and crystal size/purity don't matter.
  • Choose crystallisation when the solute would decompose on strong heating, or when large, well-formed, purer crystals are the goal.
  • Physical properties other than solubility can separate mixtures too — e.g. magnetism separates iron from non-magnetic solids without any chemical change occurring.

Filtration apparatus

Residue stays on the paper; filtrate is whatever passes through — know which one is which for the mark.

Filter funnelFilter paperResidueFiltrateRetort stand

Worked example

Separating iron and sulfur without a chemical reaction

[2]
A student mixes iron filings (Fe) and sulfur powder (S) in a beaker and wants to recover each substance separately without any chemical reaction occurring. (a) State whether the iron–sulfur combination is a mixture or a compound, giving one reason. (b) Explain how magnetic attraction can separate the iron from the sulfur.

Evaporating to dryness when crystallisation is needed

Answering 'evaporate the solution to dryness' when asked to obtain large, pure crystals of a heat-sensitive salt (e.g. copper sulfate) or when spitting/decomposition is a risk.

Consequence: Loses the method mark — copper sulfate crystals decompose/lose water of crystallisation if boiled fully dry, and rapid evaporation gives small, impure crystals, not the large pure ones the question usually asks for.

Fix: State: heat/evaporate only until the solution is saturated (test with a hot wire loop/drop test), then leave to cool slowly so large crystals form gradually, and filter off the crystals from the remaining mother liquor.

Choosing the right technique

TechniqueSeparatesProperty exploitedTypical example
FiltrationInsoluble solid from a liquidParticle size (too big to pass through paper pores)Sand from water
Evaporation (to dryness)Dissolved solute from its solventDifferent boiling points of solvent vs soluteRecovering salt quickly from salt water
CrystallisationDissolved solute, as large pure crystalsSolubility decreasing on cooling a saturated solutionPurifying copper sulfate crystals
Magnetic separationMagnetic solid from non-magnetic solid(s)MagnetismIron filings from sulfur powder

Key takeaways

  • Filtration: solid too big to pass through paper stays as residue; liquid/dissolved parts pass through as filtrate.
  • Evaporation-to-dryness is fast but destroys heat-sensitive solutes and gives small, impure crystals.
  • Crystallisation = evaporate only to saturation, then cool slowly, for large, pure crystals.
  • Not every separation relies on solubility — magnetism, particle size, and boiling point are all fair game depending on the mixture.

Distillation and Fractional Distillation

Distillation separates a liquid from dissolved solutes, or separates two miscible liquids, by exploiting differences in boiling point. In simple distillation, the mixture is heated; the component with the lowest boiling point vaporises first, travels up and through a condenser where it cools back to liquid, and is collected separately (the distillate) — this is how pure water is recovered from seawater, since dissolved salts don't vaporise at water's boiling point. Fractional distillation is used when two or more liquids with CLOSE boiling points need separating (miscible liquids, not solid-in-liquid) — a fractionating column packed with glass beads/plates provides repeated evaporation–condensation cycles up its length, letting the more volatile liquid reach the top and distil off first while the less volatile one lags behind.

  • Simple distillation: one volatile liquid + non-volatile dissolved solute(s), e.g. seawater → pure water + solid salts left behind.
  • Fractional distillation: two or more volatile liquids with similar boiling points, e.g. separating crude oil into fractions, or ethanol from a fermentation mixture.
  • The thermometer bulb must sit level with the side-arm outlet, not dipped in the liquid — it must read the temperature of the VAPOUR about to leave, confirming which component is currently boiling off.

Simple distillation apparatus

The thermometer position is the classic diagram-mark trap — bulb level with the side-arm, never in the liquid.

Thermometer (bulb level with side-arm)Round-bottom flaskHeat sourceCondenserWater inWater outReceiver/collection flaskDistillate

Worked example

Classifying substances and explaining purification by distillation

[4]
A water purification plant produces distilled water for laboratory use. A technician also has iron filings and a beaker of seawater. (a) Define 'pure substance'. (b) Classify distilled water and iron filings, justifying one classification. (c) Explain how the plant obtains pure water from seawater.

Examiner tip

Any 'explain how you'd get pure water/liquid from a mixture using distillation' question needs BOTH steps explicitly stated (heat to boiling point of the more volatile component; condense the vapour) — examiners award these as two separate marking points.

Thermometer position in the distillation diagram

Drawing (or describing) the thermometer bulb dipped into the liquid being heated.

Consequence: Loses the diagram-labelling mark — the thermometer must read the temperature of the vapour leaving through the side-arm, not the liquid's temperature.

Fix: Bulb sits exactly level with the side-arm opening, so it measures the vapour just about to distil over — this is how you confirm which substance is currently boiling off.

Real-world application

Desalination plants use large-scale simple distillation (or reverse osmosis) to turn seawater into drinking water in water-scarce regions; oil refineries use fractional distillation towers to split crude oil into petrol, kerosene, diesel and bitumen fractions by their different boiling-point ranges.

Key takeaways

  • Simple distillation: separates a volatile liquid from a non-volatile dissolved solute (e.g. water from salt).
  • Fractional distillation: separates two or more miscible liquids with close boiling points using a fractionating column.
  • Thermometer bulb must be level with the side-arm — a classic diagram mark.
  • Always state BOTH heating-to-boiling AND condensing when explaining the process.

Chromatography and Its Applications

Chromatography separates the different substances within a mixture based on how strongly each one is attracted to a stationary phase (e.g. chromatography paper) versus how soluble it is in a moving mobile phase (the solvent). Substances that cling more to the paper move slowly and stay low; substances that dissolve more readily in the solvent are carried further up. The result — a chromatogram — shows each component of the original mixture as a separate spot at its own characteristic height.

  • The baseline (starting spot line) must be drawn in pencil, never ink or pen — ink itself is a mixture of dyes that would dissolve and travel, contaminating the results.
  • The Rf (retention factor) value is characteristic of a substance for a GIVEN solvent and temperature, letting you match an unknown spot to a known reference.
  • Used in forensics (ink/drug analysis), food testing (identifying illegal dyes), and separating plant pigments (chlorophylls, carotenoids).

Retention factor (Rf)

Both distances are measured from the baseline, not from each other.

— retention factor (no unit (always between 0 and 1))
Memorise

Rf is only comparable between runs done with the SAME solvent, paper and temperature.

Paper chromatogram and Rf measurement

Both distances are measured from the same baseline — a very common measuring error.

Chromatography paper (stationary phase)Solvent (mobile phase)Pencil baselineSolvent frontMixture XReference AReference BDistance travelled by solventDistance travelled by solute

Worked example

Calculating and interpreting Rf values

[3]
A forensic chemist runs a paper chromatogram of ink from a ransom note alongside a reference pen B, using the same solvent. The solvent front travels 10.0 cm from the baseline. The note's ink separates into two spots, travelling 6.5 cm and 3.0 cm from the baseline. Reference pen B produces a single spot travelling 6.5 cm under identical conditions. (a) Calculate the Rf value of each ink spot. (b) State, with a reason, what this suggests about the ransom-note ink.

Using pen instead of pencil for the baseline

Marking the sample spots or baseline in ink/pen rather than pencil.

Consequence: The ink itself dissolves in the solvent and travels up the paper, adding extra false spots and ruining the separation — a described-method mark is lost even if the rest of the technique is correct.

Fix: Always specify pencil for the baseline: graphite is insoluble in the chromatography solvents used, so it stays put and doesn't interfere with the real spots.

Examiner tip

'Calculate' questions on Rf need the formula stated, the substitution shown, and the final value with no units (Rf is a ratio) — a bare decimal with no working shown loses the method mark even if numerically correct.

Chromatography beyond the classroom

Anti-doping labs use chromatography (paired with mass spectrometry) to detect banned substances in athlete samples; forensic scientists use it to match ink from a suspect document to a specific pen; food regulators use it to check for illegal synthetic dyes in sweets and drinks.

Key takeaways

  • Chromatography separates substances by differing attraction to stationary phase vs solubility in mobile phase.
  • Rf = distance solute travelled ÷ distance solvent travelled, both measured from the same baseline.
  • Rf is reproducible for a given substance/solvent/temperature — used to match unknowns against references.
  • Baseline must be pencil, never ink, or the baseline itself contaminates the chromatogram.

Quick Reference

Formulas

  • Solubility — always quote with a stated temperature and units g/100 g water.
  • Both distances measured from the same baseline; Rf has no units, range 0–1.

Key facts

Sharp melting point range for a pure substance
≈ ≤1 °C, compared against a literature value
Rf value range
0 to 1, no units
Thermometer bulb position in distillation
Level with the side-arm, not touching the liquid
Colloid particle size
≈ 1–1000 nm
KNO3 solubility at 60 °C (data-booklet-style curve)
110 g per 100 g water

Mnemonics

  • Solutions Simply dissolve, Colloids Scatter light, Suspensions SettleOrdered by increasing particle size and matching diagnostic test.

Don't confuse

  • Colloid vs Suspension: Colloid never settles and passes filter paper; suspension settles and is filterable.
  • Pure compound vs Mixture: Compound has one sharp melting point (fixed composition); mixture melts over a depressed range (variable composition).
  • Mixture vs Impure sample of a compound: Mixture: wide, strongly depressed range. Impure compound: small deviation close to the pure literature value.

Command terms

Define:
State composition + fixed property consequence, not just an example.
Classify:
Name the category AND the criterion used (mp range, filterability, settling).
Justify/Explain:
Tie the conclusion back to the specific data given, not a general restatement.
Calculate:
Show formula, substitution, and final answer with correct units (or state 'no units' for Rf).

Exam checklist

  • Classify using measurable behaviour (mp/bp range, settling, filterability) — never appearance alone.
  • State BOTH heating-to-boiling AND condensing when explaining distillation.
  • Rescale 'per 100 g' solubility data to the actual solvent mass given in the question.
  • Baseline in pencil for chromatography — ink contaminates the run.
  • Quote solubility with units and a stated temperature.
  • Compare an experimental melting point to a literature value to claim identity, not just purity.