IB Middle Years Programme · Physics MYP Year 5

Atomic Physics

Cover illustration for Atomic Physics (Physics MYP Year 5).
MYP · Physics MYP Year 5

Atomic Physics

30 min readStandardCore MYP Year 5 physics unit — typically assessed through Criterion A (Knowing & Understanding) and Criterion C (Communicating) tasks; data-based questions on this topic (scattering tables, decay graphs, isotope tables) are among the most frequently repeated question styles in the bank.

Atomic physics here is detective work, not memorisation. You never see a nucleus directly — you reconstruct it from how alpha particles bounce off gold foil, how long a sample takes to lose its activity, and how far radiation travels through paper, aluminium or lead. Every real exam question in this bank rewards the same skill: pull two actual numbers off a table or graph and use them to justify a conclusion about structure — not just recite 'protons are positive.'

Overview — The Shape of Atomic Physics

This topic builds in one direction: what an atom is made of, why some combinations of protons and neutrons are stable and others aren't, what happens when an unstable nucleus gives way (decay), what actually comes flying out (alpha/beta/gamma), and finally what that means for how we handle it safely. Almost every mark in the exam bank comes from linking a specific number in a table to a specific structural or safety conclusion.

  • Historical route: Thomson's plum pudding → Rutherford's gold foil evidence → Bohr's planetary model → the modern electron cloud model.
  • Nuclide identity is fixed by two counting numbers only: atomic number (protons) and mass number (protons + neutrons) — everything about isotopes and ions follows from getting these two right.
  • Decay is random for a single nucleus but statistically reliable for a huge sample — that contradiction is exactly what half-life exploits.
  • Radiation type (alpha/beta/gamma) trades ionising power against penetrating power in opposite directions — the more damaging up close, the less it travels.

The shape of the chapter

Command terms that decide your mark

Command termWhat it demandsAOMark-earning move
DescribeState a pattern or feature in detail, with no reasoning requiredAO1/AO2Cite at least two actual data values or a clear trend direction — 'it decreases' alone scores 0/2 on pattern questions like the scattering-angle tables
ExplainGive the reason or mechanism linking a cause to an effectAO2Must include the causal link ('...because...') — a bare fact with no mechanism only earns half marks
JustifySupport a stated conclusion with specific evidenceAO3Reference the actual data ('only 5 particles at 180°'), not just the general theory by itself
IdentifyName or select from given informationAO1One word/phrase is enough — extra explanation isn't credited and wastes time
DeduceUse given data to reach a conclusion that isn't stated outrightAO3Show the working chain (Z → protons → charge check), not just the final answer
EvaluateWeigh strengths and limitations to reach a balanced judgementAO3Must give a benefit AND a limitation plus a final judgement — one-sided answers cap at half marks

Key point

Every question in this topic's bank comes back to one skill: pull two numbers off a table or graph and use them to justify a structural claim. Learn the reasoning chain, not just the vocabulary.

Atomic Structure, Particles, Charges and Masses

Before Rutherford, Thomson's 'plum pudding' model pictured the atom as a blob of positive charge with electrons studded through it like fruit in a pudding — no dense centre, charge spread evenly. Rutherford, Geiger and Marsden tested this directly by firing fast alpha particles at gold foil only atoms thick and counting how many came out at each angle.

  • If plum pudding were correct, alpha particles should pass through with only tiny, gentle deflections everywhere — no route to a large-angle bounce because the positive charge is too spread out to repel strongly at any point.
  • The actual result: almost all particles pass straight through, but a small number deflect through large angles and a tiny number bounce back almost the way they came.
  • That forced a new model: a nucleus — tiny, dense, positively charged, holding almost all the mass — surrounded by mostly empty space where electrons exist.
  • Bohr then proposed fixed circular 'planetary' orbits for electrons at set energy levels; the modern quantum model replaces fixed orbits with an electron cloud — a probability distribution of where an electron is likely to be found, with no definite path.

The three sub-atomic particles

ParticleRelative chargeRelative massLocation
Proton+11Nucleus
Neutron01Nucleus
Electron-1≈1/1840 (negligible)Electron cloud outside the nucleus

Key point

A neutral atom has zero net charge because the number of orbiting electrons (each -1) always equals the number of protons in the nucleus (each +1). In helium specifically: 2 protons + 2 electrons cancel exactly, and the 2 neutrons contribute nothing to charge either way.

Rutherford's gold-foil scattering experiment

Most particles pass straight through; only the rare close encounter with a concentrated positive nucleus produces a large deflection.

alpha sourcegold foilnucleus (tiny, positive, dense)circular detector screen

Scattering angle vs particle count

The steep drop between 20° and 60°, plus the small non-zero tail at large angles, is the exact pattern examiners ask you to describe.

Scattering angle (degrees)Number of alpha particles detected

Planetary model vs electron cloud model

Fixed orbits (left) were replaced by a probability cloud (right) — no electron has a definite path in the modern model.

nucleusfixed orbitelectronregion of higher probability

Worked example

Reading a Rutherford scattering table (describe, then justify)

[4]
Scattering angle (°): 0, 10, 20, 30, 45, 60, 90, 120, 150, 180. Particles detected: 10 000, 9 500, 8 000, 5 000, 2 000, 800, 200, 50, 10, 5. (a) Describe the pattern in the data. (b) Justify what this reveals about the structure of the atom.

Worked example

Electron cloud model and the STM atom-placement claim

[4]
A company claims it can reliably place individual atoms using an STM. A critic argues Heisenberg's uncertainty principle makes this impossible. Explain how the electron cloud model differs from the planetary model, and comment on the critic's argument.

Worked example

Identifying variables in a scattering investigation

[2]
Alpha particles are fired at gold foil of varying thickness. The number of alpha particles deflected at different angles is recorded. Identify the independent and dependent variable.

Common mistake

Believing that removing one electron from a neutral atom doubles the leftover positive charge (e.g. answering '+2' instead of '+1' for a singly-ionised atom).

Consequence: Loses the mark completely — this exact confusion is deliberately tested in charge-balance evaluate questions.

Fix: Track charge as a running total starting from 0 for a neutral atom. Removing ONE electron (-1) changes the total to 0 − (−1) = +1, not +2. Only removing TWO electrons gives +2.

Key takeaways

  • Rutherford's gold-foil result (almost all particles through, a rare few bounced back) is the single dataset that killed the plum-pudding model and gave us the nuclear atom.
  • Proton +1, neutron 0, electron -1 — a neutral atom always has equal numbers of protons and electrons.
  • The modern model has no fixed orbits — electrons exist as a probability cloud, which is why uncertainty arguments target electron position, not the atom's ability to be manipulated as a whole.
  • IV/DV questions on this experiment test whether you know the experimenter sets angle/thickness, and the equipment counts particles as the outcome.

Nuclear Stability & Isotopes

Every nuclide is fully described by two numbers: the atomic number Z (protons) and the mass number A (protons + neutrons). Z decides which element it is and never changes for that element; A can vary because neutron number can vary — that variation is exactly what an isotope is.

  • Isotopes: same Z, different A, so same chemical element but different mass and often different nuclear stability — carbon-12 and carbon-14 both have 6 protons but 6 and 8 neutrons respectively.
  • Stability depends on the neutron-to-proton ratio inside the nucleus: too few or too many neutrons relative to protons leaves the nucleus unstable, and it will decay to move toward a more stable configuration.
  • Extra neutrons help offset the electrostatic repulsion between protons crammed together — that's why heavier stable nuclei need proportionally more neutrons than light ones.
  • Beyond a certain size (very heavy elements like uranium and plutonium), no neutron:proton ratio keeps the nucleus stable — these elements are naturally radioactive, which is exactly why they turn up in reactor fuel and waste.

Core vocabulary

Atomic number (Z)
The number of protons in the nucleus.Defines the element — never changes without changing what the element is.
Mass number (A)
The total number of protons and neutrons (nucleons) in the nucleus.A is never the neutron count on its own — you must subtract Z first.
Isotope
An atom of the same element (same Z) with a different number of neutrons (different A).Same chemistry, different mass and sometimes different stability.
Nuclide
A specific type of atomic nucleus, characterised by its exact Z and A.Written as .
Ion
An atom (or nuclide) with unequal numbers of protons and electrons, giving it a net charge.Ion status depends on electrons, not the nucleus — completely independent of isotope status.

Nuclide notation and particle counts

the standard way to write a nuclide, where X is the element symbol

— mass number = protons + neutrons
— atomic number = number of protons
Memorise

number of neutrons in a nucleus

— neutron number

net charge of an atom or ion, since protons are fixed by Z

— atomic number = number of protons

Carbon-12 vs carbon-14: isotopes compared

Same atomic number (Z=6), different mass number — the definition of isotopes drawn out atom by atom.

protons = 6neutrons = 6neutrons = 8

Worked example

Three particles from the same element (protons, neutrons, electrons, charge)

[6]
Particle W: A = 35, Z = 17, net charge = -1. Particle X: A = 37, Z = 17, net charge = 0. Particle Y: A = 35, Z = 17, net charge = +1. Deduce the number of protons, neutrons and electrons in each, and identify the relationship between them.

Frequently confused

Concept AConcept BThe distinction that matters
IsotopeIonIsotope status is decided purely by the nucleus (same Z, different A); ion status is decided purely by electron count (protons ≠ electrons) — one particle can be described as both an isotope AND an ion at the same time, because the labels track completely different parts of the atom.
Mass number (A)Atomic number (Z)Z never changes for a given element — it's literally what makes it that element. A changes between isotopes of the same element because neutron number varies; if Z is the same but A differs, that's an isotope, not a different element.

Common mistake

Assuming mass number A equals the number of neutrons directly.

Consequence: Directly causes wrong answers in every neutron-count question — e.g. answering 37 neutrons for particle X instead of the correct 20.

Fix: A = protons + neutrons, always. Subtract every time: neutrons = A - Z. Never read A as N directly.

Examiner tip

'Deduce' questions like the W/X/Y particle problem want the arithmetic chain shown explicitly on the page (Z → protons, A−Z → neutrons, Z−charge → electrons) — a bare final answer table with no working can lose method marks even when the numbers are correct.

Key takeaways

  • Protons define the element (Z) and never change for it; neutrons can vary — that variation IS what makes something an isotope.
  • Neutron count = A − Z, always subtract, never assume A is the neutron number.
  • Charge = protons − electrons: negative net charge means MORE electrons, positive net charge means FEWER electrons than protons.
  • Very heavy nuclei can't find a stable neutron:proton ratio at any mass — that's precisely why uranium- and plutonium-family isotopes are radioactive and turn up as reactor waste.

Radioactivity: Nuclear and Decay

An unstable nucleus (wrong neutron:proton ratio, or simply too heavy) sheds particles or energy to move toward stability — this is radioactive decay. It's spontaneous and random at the level of a single nucleus: you can never predict which nucleus decays or exactly when, and nothing chemical or physical (temperature, pressure, chemical bonding) changes that rate — it's a purely nuclear property.

  • Alpha decay: the nucleus emits a helium nucleus (2 protons + 2 neutrons) — A drops by 4, Z drops by 2, forming a new element (transmutation).
  • Beta decay: a neutron converts into a proton plus an emitted high-speed electron (the beta particle) — A stays the same, Z rises by 1, again forming a new element.
  • Gamma decay: the nucleus emits a high-energy photon to shed excess energy — no change in A or Z at all; it often follows alpha or beta decay to release leftover energy.
  • Half-life is the time for the number of undecayed nuclei (or the activity) in a sample to fall to half its previous value — repeated halving means the amount never reaches exactly zero, it's an exponential decrease.

Decay equations and half-life

alpha decay: mass number drops by 4, atomic number drops by 2

beta decay: mass number unchanged, atomic number rises by 1 (a neutron becomes a proton)

number of undecayed nuclei remaining after time t

— remaining undecayed nuclei
— initial number of undecayed nuclei
— elapsed time
— half-life
Memorise

Decay curve for Pu-239

Each 24 100-year interval halves whatever remains — the curve gets flatter but never touches zero.

Time (years)Number of undecayed nuclei (arbitrary units)

Fraction remaining after n half-lives

Number of half-livesFraction remaining% remaining
01100%
11/250%
21/425%
31/812.5%
41/166.25%
101/1024≈0.1%

Worked example

Pu-239 waste: half-life across geological timescales

[6]
Plutonium-239 has a half-life of 24 100 years. A sample starts at 800 arbitrary units. (a) Calculate how much remains after 72 300 years. (b) Calculate how much remains after 36 150 years. (c) Justify why storage timescales are often quoted far beyond one or two half-lives.

Key point

Radioactive decay is random for any single nucleus (you can never say WHEN a given atom will decay) but statistically reliable for a huge sample — that's exactly why an exam can confidently quote '24 100 years' for Pu-239 while also treating deep geological storage as inherently risky over such timescales (seismic activity, groundwater flow).

Common mistake

Treating half-life as linear — assuming that after 2 half-lives none of the sample is left, or that the amount decreases by the same fixed number every half-life.

Consequence: Produces answers like '0 remaining' or uses subtraction instead of halving, losing all calculation marks.

Fix: Halving is multiplicative, not subtractive: N0 → N0/2 → N0/4 → N0/8 ... never N0 − x, N0 − 2x.

Examiner tip

When elapsed time is an exact multiple of the half-life, you can halve step-by-step and skip the formula — but the moment the numbers don't divide exactly, switch to immediately; interpolating by eye between table values is not accepted as valid working.

Key takeaways

  • Alpha decay: A drops by 4, Z drops by 2 (loses a helium nucleus). Beta decay: A unchanged, Z rises by 1 (a neutron becomes a proton). Gamma: no change in A or Z, just energy loss.
  • Half-life = time for the amount/activity to halve — halve repeatedly for whole multiples, use the formula for fractional ones.
  • Decay is random for one nucleus, statistically predictable for a large sample — that's what lets us quote a precise half-life at all.
  • Because decay is exponential (never truly zero), 'safe' storage timescales are set at many multiples of the half-life, not just one or two.

Forms of Radiation: Properties, Uses & Detection

Alpha, beta and gamma differ in what they are, and that single fact determines everything else about them — how far they travel, how strongly they ionise, what stops them, and what they're used for.

  • Alpha particle: a helium nucleus (2 protons + 2 neutrons), charge +2, relatively heavy and slow — very strongly ionising over a very short range, stopped by paper or a few cm of air.
  • Beta particle: a fast-moving electron, charge -1, much lighter than alpha — moderately ionising, penetrates further, stopped by a few mm of aluminium.
  • Gamma ray: a high-energy electromagnetic photon, no charge, no mass — weakly ionising per interaction but travels furthest, only significantly reduced (never fully stopped) by thick lead or metres of concrete.
  • Detection matches the mechanism: Geiger-Müller tubes count ionising events as clicks, photographic film/badges darken with cumulative exposure, cloud chambers show visible ionisation trails, spark counters show visible sparks (mainly alpha).

Alpha, beta and gamma compared

PropertyAlpha (α)Beta (β)Gamma (γ)
IdentityHelium nucleus (2p + 2n)Fast-moving electronHigh-energy EM photon
Charge+2-10
Relative mass4 (heavy)≈1/1840 (very light)0 (massless)
Ionising powerVery highModerateLow per interaction
Penetrating powerVery low — stopped by paper or a few cm of airModerate — stopped by a few mm of aluminiumVery high — only reduced by thick lead/concrete
Typical detectorSpark counter, close-range GM tubeGM tube, cloud chamberGM tube, photographic film/scintillation counter

Penetrating power through materials

Penetrating power order: gamma > beta > alpha — matched to the thinnest material that blocks each.

radioactive sourcepaperaluminiumlead/concrete

Mnemonic

Alice Ate Paper, Bob Blocked with foil, Gary Guards with Lead

Alpha is stopped by paper, Beta is stopped by aluminium foil, Gamma needs lead/thick concrete (and is never fully stopped) — the sillier the sentence, the easier the order sticks under exam pressure.

Smoke detectors run on alpha decay

Household ionisation smoke detectors contain a tiny americium-241 source. Its alpha particles constantly ionise the air in a small chamber, producing a steady tiny current between two electrodes; smoke particles entering the chamber absorb the alpha radiation and disrupt that current, triggering the alarm. It works precisely because alpha radiation is short-range and easily absorbed — completely stopped by the plastic casing plus a few cm of air — making it low-risk in normal use despite being the most heavily ionising radiation type of the three.

Key takeaways

  • Ionising power and penetrating power run in opposite directions: alpha is most damaging per collision but travels least; gamma barely ionises per interaction but travels furthest.
  • Stopping order: paper (alpha) → aluminium (beta) → thick lead/concrete (gamma, only reduced, never fully stopped).
  • A GM tube detects all three — which barrier the source sits behind tells you which type(s) you're actually detecting.
  • Match use to property: alpha for sealed smoke detectors, beta for thickness gauges (partial transmission), gamma for medical imaging/sterilisation (needs to penetrate tissue or packaging).

Dangers of Radiation & Safety Measures

All three radiation types are ionising — they can strip electrons from atoms and molecules in living cells, damaging DNA directly or via reactive free radicals, which can cause cell death or mutation. Managing the risk always comes down to controlling three things: how long you're exposed, how far you are from the source, and what's between you and it.

  • Irradiation: being exposed to radiation from an external source — you are NOT radioactive afterward (like having an X-ray taken).
  • Contamination: radioactive material actually gets onto or into your body (skin, inhaled, ingested) — exposure continues until it's physically removed or decays, and it can spread to others or to surfaces.
  • Safety levers: TIME (minimise exposure duration), DISTANCE (intensity falls off rapidly moving away from a point source), SHIELDING (correct barrier for the radiation type — lead/concrete for gamma) — plus sealed sources, remote handling tools, and monitoring badges for workers.
  • Background radiation exists naturally from cosmic rays, rocks, radon gas and food — safety limits and dose comparisons are always set relative to this existing baseline, not against zero.

Frequently confused

Concept AConcept BThe distinction that matters
IrradiationContaminationIrradiation stops the instant you leave the radiation field — you were exposed, but you're not radioactive. Contamination means radioactive material is physically on or in you, so exposure continues until it's removed or decays.

Common mistake

Describing someone who simply stood near a radioactive source (irradiation only) as 'now radioactive' or 'contaminated'.

Consequence: Loses marks in any safety/evaluation question that distinguishes exposure routes, including waste-storage risk discussions.

Fix: Ask: did radioactive material actually transfer onto or into the person? If no (just exposure to a field), it's irradiation only — not contamination.

Key point

Dose reduction always comes down to the same three levers — Time, Distance, Shielding — whether you're designing a hospital radiotherapy suite or a nuclear waste repository. Naming the specific lever being used scores better than a vague 'be careful with it' answer.

Deep geological repositories

Finland's Onkalo facility buries spent nuclear fuel roughly 400–450 m underground in stable bedrock, sealed in copper canisters surrounded by bentonite clay designed to swell and self-seal if disturbed — a direct real-world answer to the seismic-activity and groundwater-flow risks raised in nuclear waste storage scenarios.

Examiner tip

Evaluate/discuss questions on nuclear waste storage expect a balanced answer: at least one genuine risk (e.g. groundwater transporting leaked material) AND one mitigating design feature (multiple containment barriers, careful site geology) with an explicit final judgement — listing risks with no mitigation, or vice versa, caps the answer at half marks.

Key takeaways

  • All ionising radiation can damage DNA; risk scales with dose AND how ionising the specific radiation type is — alpha is worst if it gets inside the body, despite being weakest from outside.
  • Irradiation = exposed only; contamination = radioactive material still on/in you — identify which one a scenario describes before answering.
  • Reduce dose via time, distance and shielding — plus containment and monitoring for occupational safety.
  • Long-lived waste (e.g. Pu-239, half-life 24 100 years) needs storage that survives geological-scale risks: seismic activity and groundwater intrusion are the two hazards examiners keep testing.

Quick Reference

Formulas

  • neutron number from mass and atomic number
  • negative charge = extra electrons
  • alpha decay: A−4, Z−2
  • beta decay: A same, Z+1
  • remaining nuclei after time t; use for fractional half-lives

Key facts

Alpha particle relative mass
4
Beta particle charge
-1
Gamma particle mass and charge
0 and 0
Pu-239 half-life
24 100 years
Neutron relative charge
0

Mnemonics

  • Alice Ate Paper, Bob Blocked with foil, Gary Guards with LeadStopping order: alpha-paper, beta-aluminium, gamma-lead/concrete

Don't confuse

  • Isotope vs Ion: Isotope = nucleus property (same Z, different A); Ion = electron-count property (protons ≠ electrons) — independent labels
  • Mass number (A) vs Atomic number (Z): Z fixes the element and never changes; A varies between isotopes of that same element
  • Irradiation vs Contamination: Irradiation ends when you leave the field; contamination means the radioactive material is still on/in you

Command terms

Describe:
cite at least two actual data values or a clear trend
Explain:
give the causal mechanism, not just a fact
Justify:
link the specific data back to the stated conclusion
Deduce:
show the full working chain, not just the final numbers
Evaluate:
give a benefit AND a limitation plus a final judgement

Exam checklist

  • Can you read a scattering/decay graph and quote at least two numeric values in a 'describe' answer?
  • Can you go from A and Z to protons/neutrons/electrons for both atoms AND ions?
  • Can you balance an alpha or beta decay equation, checking A and Z conservation on both sides?
  • Can you handle a half-life calculation when elapsed time is NOT a whole multiple of the half-life?
  • Can you correctly order alpha/beta/gamma by penetrating power AND state what stops each one?
  • Can you distinguish irradiation from contamination in a given safety scenario?